Keeping My Tween Silent about Santa
Posted on December 21st, 2010 by Kristen Paulsen
It was just yesterday that my tween was screaming as I tried to get a picture with her and Santa. Then she loved him and believed in him and wanted to take pictures, write letters and leave cookies. Now, well, we have to keep her silent as not to ruin her younger siblings magical beliefs.
It was last year that she questioned his existence. Then it happened. I messed up. I wrapped “Santa’s” gift with the same paper as another gift from us. The result of an innocent mistake was a confirmation she had long been waiting for.
Many kids start questioning the belief of Santa around 8 years old. Then more and more children start making fun of others who still believe. My daughter questioned for a year or so but held out for the magic in her heart. Then, she was too observant and had too many unanswered questions about the validity of the “North Pole” and people realistically being able to sustain life in the temperatures and environment. Logic prevailed.
We have been trying to have her keep the silence and she has humored us by slyly smiling as phone calls to Santa (grandpa) are made, letters are written, cookies are made to be left, etc. She has asked us why we should “deceive” my son with the belief. Our youngest is still too young to believe yet. We simply said, “don’t shatter others’ beliefs, we still believe.”
This discovery also led to all the other “magical” holiday fairies’ validity. Hence, I get handed a tooth and asked for the “fairy money.” To which I reply, “there is no payment beyond disbelief.”
The sad reality of my growing tween!
Has your tween discovered “Santa?” How and when do you manage our tween with their questioning minds?





or stick to the traditional December 25th schedule? I know there are a lot of us in this boat; every military wife/husband will consider this at one point or another. So what am I going to do?